Cabana Sam's Restaurant Menu


The Mambo Combo
All of the favorites to share. Buffalo chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, and pizza fingers. Served with marinara sauce and bleu cheese.   $13.49

Caribbean Coconut Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp rolled in a delicious coconut batter and lightly fried. Served with waffle fries and pina colada sauce.   $9.49

Tater Tot Tornado
A twister full of tots! Seasoned tater tots served one of three ways: Sea Salt & Pepper, Garlic Parm, or Buffalo style with dipping sauces. GF.   $9.49

Bam Bam Shrimp
Fried shrimp tossed in our sweet and tangy Bam Bam sauce with a little bit of heat.   $11.99

Chips & Guacamole
Tortilla chips served with our house-made Guacamole. GF.  $6.99

Pickles & Rings
Battered Kosher pickle fries served with beer-battered onion rings and ranch dressing.  $9.99

Skin Divers
Homemade potato skins topped with cheddar cheese and bacon with sour cream on the side. GF.   $9.29

Pan-fried tortilla stuffed with a combination of Monterrey Jack & cheddar cheeses, diced tomatoes, black olives, jalapeno peppers, sour cream, and salsa.   $8.99
Add grilled chicken breast for $2.99 extra.

Chicken Fingers
Breaded chicken tenderloins served Buffalo style – mild, medium, or hot. Served with french fries and bleu cheese.   $11.99

Fried Calamari
Crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. Served with cocktail sauce.   $9.99

Cabana Crab Cakes
Made with real crab meat. Served with Remoulade & cocktail sauce.   $11.49

Loaded Cross Fries or Tots
Seasoned cross fries or tater tots loaded with bacon, cheddar cheese, sour cream, and diced scallions.   $10.49

Chicken Wings
Mild, medium or hot…add $1.00 for BBQ, Cajun, or Cajun BBQ. All served with bleu cheese, carrots, and celery. GF.   Single order (10) $11.49  |  Double order (20) $21.99

Nachos Supreme
Nacho chips piled high and topped with cheddar cheese, tomato, onion, jalapeños and black olives. Served with a side of sour cream and salsa.   $9.49   Add grilled chicken breast or beef for $2.99 extra.

Pizza Fingers
Breaded “pizza” fingers made with mozzarella cheese, pizza sauce, and pepperoni. Rolled up and served with a side of marinara sauce.   $10.99

Loaded Antipasto Pretzel 

Oversized soft pretzel topped with a variety of Italian deli meats, chunk cheeses, olives and peppers. Big enough for all to share!  $14.99

Soft Pretzel Sticks 
Baked soft pretzel sticks served with beer cheese and honey mustard dipping sauces.   $7.99

Original Crunch Rolls
Wrapped in a crispy crunch shell providing its unique CRUNCH. Two styles to choose from: HUNGARIAN BANANA PEPPER mixed with a four-cheese blend and spices or BUFFALO CHICKEN cooked in spicy Buffalo sauce and mixed with a special blend of cheeses. Made here in Chautauqua County!   $9.99

Mozzarella Sticks
Served with a side of marinara sauce.   $7.99

Basket of Fries or Tots
Crispy battered fries.    $3.99
Add cheese for $.50 extra.

Basket of Onion Rings
Served with Horseradish dipping sauce.    $3.49



Cabana Sam’s Caesar
Romaine lettuce tossed with croutons, creamy Caesar dressing, and fresh Parmesan cheese.   $9.49
Add grilled chicken breast or grilled shrimp for $2.99 extra.

California Cobb Salad
Seasonal greens topped with grilled chicken breast, avocado, bacon, tomatoes, egg, and crumbly bleu cheese.   $13.99

Apple Walnut Salad
A great summer salad! Fresh greens with apple slices, Craisins, toasted walnuts, and mandarin oranges. Served with maple vinaigrette dressing.   $9.99
Add grilled chicken breast for $2.99 extra.

Chicken Salad Plate
Cool summer favorite! House-made chicken salad with creamy mayo, candied walnuts and craisins. Served on a bed of lettuce.  $11.99

Pittsburgh Salad
Seasonal greens topped with your choice of marinated steak or grilled chicken. Topped with cross fries and cheeses. Served with warm Riviera dressing.   $12.99

Mango Grouper Salad
Blackened grouper fillet topped with mango salsa, served over fresh greens with pepper-jack cheese and served with mango vinaigrette dressing.   $13.99

Soup of the Day
Cup $3.49   Bowl $4.49

Dinner Salad
Mixed greens with your choice of dressing.   $3.49

Bowl of Crab Bisque
Housemade, creamy bisque with real crab meat.   Cup $4.49   Bowl $5.49



Burgers are served with seasoned fries or tater tots. Substitute a dinner salad for only $1.50
Sandwiches are served with our homemade Sunset seasoned chips. Substitute seasoned french fries or tater tots for $1.25
Gluten-free sandwich roll or wrap available for $1 extra

Steak & “Seaweed” Sandwich
Okay, it’s not really seaweed! Shaved Sirloin steak topped with sautéed spinach, onions, and melted Monterrey Jack cheese. Served on a toasted garlic roll with bleu cheese.   $12.99

Island Grouper Sandwich
Tasty blackened grouper fillet with lettuce and tomato then topped with our mango mayo. Served on a Costanzo hoagie roll.   $14.99

Crab Cake Po’ Boy Hoagie
A classic southern favorite! Our Cabana Sam’s Crab Cakes served on a Costanzo hoagie roll with lettuce, tomato, onion, and Remoulade sauce.   $12.99  Add cheese for $0.50

French Dip Sandwich
Tender, slow-cooked roast beef with sautéed mushrooms and onions. Topped with melted provolone and served on a hoagie roll with au jus sauce.    $10.99

The Beach Club
Triple decker combo of turkey breast with bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Topped with mayo.   $9.49

Beef on Weck
Our own slow-roasted and seasoned roast beef served hot on a ‘weck roll with a side of horseradish and au jus.   $9.99

Chicken Salad Sandwich
House-made chicken salad with creamy mayo, candied walnuts and craisins. Topped with provolone cheese and served on a Ciabatta roll.   $8.99

The Classic Reuben
Made with lean corned beef and sauerkraut. Topped with melted Swiss cheese and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread.   $9.99

The Grouper Reuben
Blackened grouper fillet with coleslaw, melted Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread.   $10.99

Turkey Reuben
Deli-style turkey breast piled high with coleslaw, melted Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread.   $9.99

Sunset Supreme Steak Sandwich
Shaved Sirloin covered with melted mozzarella and cheddar cheeses. Topped with sautéed peppers & onions and served on a hoagie roll.   $12.99

The Stinger Hoagie
Costanzo’s hoagie roll stuffed with chicken fingers tossed in our wing sauce, shaved prime rib, sautéed peppers and onions and served on a hoagie roll.   $12.99

Charbroiled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Choose original or BB, Cheddar, and Bacon all served on a rustic artisan roll. one of our specialties all served on a rustic artisan roll.
Original Charbroiled $10.99  |  BBQ, Cheddar, and Bacon $11.49

Chipotle Black Bean “Burger”
A delicious, meat-free burger alternative that is gluten-free and vegetarian. Served on a rustic artisan roll with pepper jack cheese, avocado, lettuce, tomato, onion, and garlic mayo.   $10.99

Sunrise Burger
Breakfast and a burger, all in one! Our half-pound burger topped with American and provolone cheese, crisp bacon, and a sunny-side-up egg.    $12.49

Half Pound Burger
A half pound of beef grilled the way you like it. Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.   $10.99
Add your choice of cheese for $0.50 extra. Add bacon for $1.00 extra.

Cheeseburger in Paradise
We take our half pound and top it with bleu cheese, melted cheddar, and bacon and then we “run it through the garden.”   $12.99

The “O.R.B.”
Which stands for The Onion Ring Burger. Our half-pound burger topped with melted Swiss cheese, crispy onion rings, lettuce, and tomato. Then finished with our house-made horseradish sauce.   $12.49

Buffalo Bleu Burger
Buffalo wing flavor on a burger… half pound burger covered in our wing sauce, made with Frank’s Original Red Hot Sauce, and topped with crumbly bleu cheese.   $12.49



Served Daily after 4 pm
Entrees include choice of potato, daily vegetable, and house salad unless otherwise specified
Pasta dishes are served with a house salad and garlic bread
Gluten-free penne pasta available for $1 extra

Sweet Chili Chicken
Chicken breast marinated in a mild sweet chili sauce and grilled. Topped with melted pepper jack cheese and served over rice pilaf.   $15.99

Ultimate Fisherman’s Platter
A platter full of favorites! Fried wild Alaskan cod fillet, Maryland crab cake, and fried shrimp. Served with french fries and coleslaw.   $20.99*

Caribbean Pork Chops
Marinated and charbroiled pork chops topped with our mango-lime salsa. Served over rice pilaf.  $16.99
Add a grilled shrimp skewer for $2.99 extra.

Coconut Shrimp Dinner
8 Jumbo shrimp prepared in a coconut batter for a sweet and crunchy flavor. Served with pina colada sauce for dipping.   $18.49

Sesame Jack Chicken Strips
Crispy fried chicken strips with toasted sesame seeds in a BBQ bourbon glaze. Served with fries and coleslaw.   $13.99*

The SunSetter Steak
A tender and tasty 10-ounce hanger steak seasoned with our sunset spices and cooked to your liking.   $20.99
Add a grilled shrimp skewer for $2.99 extra.

Grouper Platter
A large, tender grouper fillet prepared with Cajun, Blackened, or Lemon-Pepper spices and served with choice of potato or rice pilaf.  $18.99

Fish & Chips
Wild Alaskan cod fillets deep fried and served with crispy french fries and coleslaw.   $14.49*

Fettuccine Alfredo
Generous portion of pasta topped in our homemade Alfredo sauce.   $12.99
Add broccoli for $1.00. Add chicken & broccoli for $3.49 extra.

Bourbon Glazed Hanger Steak
Hanger steak, also called the ‘butcher’s steak,’ is a tender and flavorful steak that we glaze with our own special Jim Beam bourbon sauce. Topped with sauteed mushrooms and onions.   $21.99
Add a grilled shrimp skewer for $2.99 extra.

Red Pepper Crab Haddock
House-seasoned broiled haddock topped with a crabmeat stuffing, pepper jack cheese, and red pepper sauce. Served over rice pilaf. $20.99

Cabana Sam’s Fried Chicken
Generous portion of our crispy, juicy house-made fried chicken in a seasoned buttermilk batter. Served with cheddar mashed potatoes or French fries and coleslaw.   $14.99

Shrimp in a Basket
Fried shrimp served with french fries, coleslaw, and a side of cocktail sauce. Also available Buffalo-style.   $14.49*

*Add a salad to these entrees for just $1.50



Wraps and paninis are served with our homemade Sunset seasoned chips. Substitute a house salad, seasoned french fries or tater tots for $1.25
Gluten-free sandwich roll or wrap available for $1 extra.

Bacon Chicken Ranch Panini
Grilled chicken topped with crisp bacon, cheddar cheese, and ranch dressing. Grilled on panini bread.   $11.49

Fiesta Fish Burrito
Cajun broiled haddock in a cheddar jalapeno wrap stuffed with shredded lettuce, pepper jack cheese, southwest coleslaw, and pico de gallo.   $10.49

California Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, shredded Monterrey Jack cheese and sliced avocado topped with garlic mayo and served in a wheat tortilla.   $10.99

Turkey Club Melt
Sliced turkey, crisp bacon, cheddar cheese and tomato. Topped with mayo and grilled on panini bread.   $11.49

Portobello Mushroom Melt
A large marinated portobello mushroom topped with chopped spinach, roasted red peppers, provolone cheese, and garlic mayo. Grilled on panini bread.   $10.99

Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled marinated chicken with romaine lettuce, tomatoes, and Caesar dressing served in a wheat tortilla.   $10.49

The Beach Burrito
Spicy taco meat, cheddar and Monterrey Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, salsa, and sour cream. Served in a cheddar jalapeno wrap.   $9.99

Fajita Grill Wrap
Your choice of marinated steak or chicken, cheddar cheese, fried peppers and onions, lettuce, tomato, salsa and sour cream. Served in a cheddar jalapeno wrap.   $10.49

Buffalo Wrap
Cheddar jalapeno wrap filled with lightly breaded chicken tenderloins, lettuce, tomato and our spicy bleu cheese sauce.   $9.49

Crazy Turkey Wrap
Grilled wheat tortilla with sliced turkey, Craisins, glazed walnuts, romaine lettuce, mozzarella cheese, and cranberry mayo $10.99



Clams on the Half Shell
(1/2 Dozen) $14.49 (Dozen)

(1/2 Dozen) $14.49 (Dozen)

Clams Casino   $8.99 (1/2 Dozen Only)


BEVERAGES – We proudly serve PEPSI products

Soda Pop   $2.50

Pink Lemonade or Loganberry $2.50

Milk or Juice   $1.50

Iced Tea   $2.50 

Coffee, Hot Tea   $1.50

Bottled spring water   $2.00

Red Bull Can  $4.00